The hidden world of fern reproduction

Despite collecting thousands of fern specimens and even writing a book about fern identification, Botany Curator Leon Perrie recently mistook a fern for a liverwort. It might seem a basic error, but he and Te Papa geneticist Lara Shepherd explain that it reflects how little is known about the reproduction of ferns, even though they are all around us in Aotearoa New Zealand.

During the 2024 John Child Bryophyte and Lichen Workshop near Whangārei, we collected what Leon thought was a liverwort. It wasn’t a species he recognised, but its elongated, ribbon-like body without leaves resembled that of thalloid liverworts.

A close-up photo of a liverwort in the wild.
Leon provisionally identified this in the field as a thalloid liverwort, but Lara used DNA sequencing to show that it was the filmy fern Hymenophyllum demissum.  Photo Leon Perrie. Te Papa.

Back at the Workshop’s base, Leon couldn’t get a satisfactory answer with the identification key for thalloid liverworts in New Zealand. On showing our specimen to other Workshop participants, ecological consultant Marley Ford said that he had collected something similar recently, and that liverwort expert David Glenny had identified it as a fern!

A photo of a liverwort growing on tree, potenitally. The photo is close in to the liverwort itself so you can't see what is around it.
Marley’s collection that he initially thought might be a thalloid liverwort. Lara used DNA sequencing to show it was the filmy fern Hymenophyllum revolutum. Photo by Marley Ford

DNA to the rescue

Could our collection be a fern too?  If so, which fern?

Lara had the means to answer that. For both our sample and Marley’s, Lara sequenced a short region of DNA regularly used to infer relationships among plants. The results were clear: the DNA of our sample matched the DNA from another sample identified as the filmy fern Hymenophyllum demissum, while Marley’s sample was a match for H. revolutum.

A split image of two photos of two different fern fronds. One has smaller leaves and one has much bigger ones.
The filmy ferns Hymenophyllum demissum (irirangi), at left, and H. revolutum (without a colloquial name).  Photos by Leon Perrie. Te Papa

Hymenophyllum demissum and H. revolutum are common and widespread filmy ferns in New Zealand. But our liverwort-like samples look nothing like these ferns, so what is going on?

Plant reproduction 101

To reconcile the DNA results with the specimens, we first need to appreciate that land plants have two phases to their life cycle. These are:

  • a sexual gametophyte phase that produces gametes (i.e., ‘eggs’ and ‘sperm’),
  • an asexual sporophyte phase with twice the number of chromosomes that produces spores via meiosis.

The ‘Alternation of Generations’ explained by Wikipedia.

In mosses and liverworts, it is the gametophyte phase that is physically dominant, with the sporophyte smaller and nutritionally dependent on the gametophyte. But in the land plants that we’re most familiar with – the seed plants (including flowering plants and conifers) and ferns – it is the sporophyte that is dominant, while the gametophytes are smaller and hidden.

The fern life-cycle

Ferns differ from seed plants, mosses, and liverworts in that the gametophytes and sporophytes of ferns are both capable of making their own energy (via photosynthesis) rather than one being nutritionally dependent on the other.

Illustration of a fern life-cycle, with alternation between spore-producing sporophyte and gamete-producing gametophyte phases. Not to scale: fern gametophytes are usually about one centimetre across or less and spores are generally about 0.05 mm long.  The sporophyte is what we typically think of as a ‘fern’. It has two sets of chromosomes, and produces spores by meiosis in its reproductive structures on the underside or margins of its fertile fronds. Each spore is single-celled, with one set of chromosomes. The spores are small enough to be carried in the wind. They are produced in vast numbers (millions from a big frond), but only a tiny fraction land in a suitable place for them to germinate into a gametophyte. Fern gametophytes can be female producing eggs that they hold onto, or male producing sperm that are released to swim towards eggs, or hermaphrodite. Egg and sperm both have only one set of chromosomes. If a sperm fertilises an egg, their chromosome sets are joined together, and a new sporophyte with two sets of chromosomes can develop. 2n and n indicates two sets and one set of chromosomes, respectively.

The fronded plants that we’re familiar with as ferns are sporophytes. With a few asexual exceptions, all the sporophyte ferns we see have grown from a fertilised egg held by a gametophyte. Since sporophyte ferns are all around us, their progenitor gametophytes must be too, but they are much harder to spot. Have you ever seen one?

Small leaves on a rock. In the bottom-left corner is a partial finger and fingernail.
Fern gametophytes with the usual heart-shape.  Some have young sporophytes. Identity unknown. Fingernail at bottom-left for scale. Photo Leon Perrie. Te Papa

Most fern gametophytes are heart-shaped, less than one centimetre in diameter, and short lived (perhaps up to a year). A good place to look for them is on recently cut earth banks or on the root plates of upturned trees.  We rarely notice them elsewhere, even though they must be widespread.

These heart-shaped plants can be readily identified as fern gametophytes, especially if some of them have an uncurling koru or fiddlehead of a young frond of a fern sporophyte growing out of them. But the general appearance of heart-shaped gametophytes is very similar among species and even across genera and families, meaning they are difficult/impossible to distinguish without genetic testing.

However, some fern groups, especially those that are generally epiphytic, have different-looking gametophytes. For instance, the gametophytes of the filmy ferns Hymenophyllum and Trichomanes are branching ribbons and branching filaments (i.e., narrower), respectively. And both can be longer-lived.

Which brings us back to the collections that Leon and Marley initially identified as thalloid liverworts, but which Lara used DNA sequencing to identify as Hymenophyllum filmy ferns – our collections are gametophytes of these species.

Fern gametophytes: underappreciated and under-documented

Because they are difficult to spot and to identify, fern gametophytes have been largely ignored during the investigation of the New Zealand flora. New Zealand’s public herbaria – collections of dried plant specimens – have in their care some 70,000 specimens of New Zealand fern sporophytes, but seemingly fewer than 20 specimens of fern gametophytes. Such a small number provides little insight.

We know little about how the appearance of fern gametophytes may vary in New Zealand. For instance, Marley’s collection looks different to Leon and Lara’s, but is that because of species-level differences or environmental influence?

Excepting some studies from the early 20th century and a recent investigation in tree ferns, little is known about the ecology of fern gametophytes in New Zealand. For instance, to what extent do they occur beyond the distribution of their sporophytes?  Overseas, the gametophytes of at least 20 fern species have been found in regions where their sporophytes are absent.

Can you find them?

If you’ve an interest and eye for the small and underappreciated in nature, look out for fern gametophytes. It’s a cryptic world ripe with discovery.

Given their current rarity, it would be valuable to collect specimens for public herbaria of fern gametophytes that can be identified. Photos uploaded to iNaturalist may also be useful.

Finally, a couple of tips to avoid our initial errors: fern gametophytes are only one cell thick (may need a microscope to confirm) whereas thalloid liverworts are several cells thick (at least at their mid-vein), and some thalloid liverworts have a mid-vein whereas fern gametophytes do not.

An image split into three with different types of green liverwort leaf shapes.
Some of the thalloid liverworts with a similar appearance to the gametophytes of Hymenophyllum filmy ferns. From top to bottom: Symphyogyna, Metzgeria, and Riccardia.  Photos by Leon Perrie.  Te Papa

For more

The paper by Leon, Marley, and Lara detailing our investigation is freely available from Te Papa’s Tuhinga journal:

Perrie L, Ford M, Shepherd L. 2026. DNA-based identification of fern gametophytes from two different species of Hymenophyllum in Aotearoa New Zealand.  Tuhinga 37: 55-62.  DOI:10.3897/tuhinga.37.211324

This Te Papa blog post is about the 2024 book Identification Guide to the Ferns and Lycophytes of Aotearoa New Zealand, which deals with fern sporophytes:

https://blog.tepapa.govt.nz/2025/01/31/summer-fern-hunting/


Enjoying these blogs?

Even a small donation helps Te Papa continue making its collections and research accessible to everyone.