Tag Archives: Asplenium bulbiferum

Is your hen and chickens fern a fake?

Are you growing a hen & chickens fern at home? If so, chances are it’s a fake, unless you dug it out of the bush.

Hen & chickens ferns get their common name from their production of bulbils, or vegetative outgrowths, on the upperside of their fronds. These bulbils are the ‘chickens’ and the fronds are the mother ‘hen’. The bulbils can grow into new individuals, as a clone of their parent.

A bulbil, or ‘chicken', of a hen & chickens fern. These are a vegetative, non-sexual mode of reproduction.

A bulbil, or ‘chicken', of a hen & chickens fern. These are a vegetative, non-sexual mode of reproduction. Photo by Leon Perrie. (c) Leon Perrie, Wellington.

True hen & chickens fern – Asplenium bulbiferum – is found in the wild only in New Zealand.

Asplenium bulbiferum has closely-set frond segments, and usually many bulbils.

Asplenium bulbiferum has closely-set frond segments, and usually many bulbils. Photo by Leon Perrie. (c) Leon Perrie, Wellington.

In addition to Asplenium bulbiferum, one other hen & chickens fern is native to New Zealand: Asplenium gracillimum. It is also native to Australia. Asplenium gracillimum is an allopolyploid of Asplenium bulbiferum and Asplenium hookerianum, being derived from hybridisation and a doubling of chromosome number.

Caption

Compared to Asplenium bulbiferum, Asplenium gracillimum has more diamond-shaped fronds, more space between its frond segments, and often only a few or even no bulbils. Photo by Leon Perrie. (c) Leon Perrie, Wellington.

Occasional plants of Asplenium gracillimum have very narrow frond segments. These have sometimes been incorrectly called Asplenium bulbiferum variety tripinnatum.

Asplenium gracillimum with narrow frond segments. These resemble the fertile fronds of Asplenium ×lucrosum (see below), but they can be distinguished by all of the fronds having narrow segments, rather than having both broad (when without spore-producing structures) and narrow (when with spore-producing structures) segments. Photo by Leon Perrie. (c) Leon Perrie, Wellington.

Asplenium gracillimum with narrow frond segments. These resemble the fertile fronds of Asplenium ×lucrosum (see below), but they can be distinguished by all of the fronds having narrow segments, rather than having both broad (when without spore-producing structures) and narrow (when with spore-producing structures) segments. Photo by Leon Perrie. (c) Leon Perrie, Wellington.

Most hen & chickens in cultivation are actually sterile hybrid plants properly called Asplenium ×lucrosum, despite usually being mislabelled by plant-sellers as Asplenium bulbiferum. Asplenium ×lucrosum is not native to New Zealand, but is a hybrid that arose in cultivation; its origin is a fascinating story.

Asplenium ×lucrosum and Asplenium bulbiferum are frequently confused, and not only by plant nurseries: most books and websites pertaining to illustrate Asplenium bulbiferum actually feature Asplenium ×lucrosum!

The false hen & chickens fern - Asplenium ×lucrosum - has dimorphic, or two very different looking, fronds on the same individual. The fronds with spore-producing structures have much narrower frond segments than fronds without. This difference in form can even occur within a single frond if it has regions with and without reproductive structures. Asplenium bulbiferum and Asplenium gracillimum do not have dimorphic fronds. Photo by Leon Perrie, Curator. (c) Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa.

The false hen & chickens fern - Asplenium ×lucrosum - has dimorphic fronds (i.e., two different looking kinds of fronds) on the same individual. The fronds with spore-producing structures have much narrower frond segments than fronds without. This difference in form can even occur within a single frond if it has regions with and without spore-producing structures. Asplenium bulbiferum and Asplenium gracillimum do not have dimorphic fronds. Photo by Leon Perrie, Curator. (c) Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa.

Close relatives of the Asplenium bulbiferum and Asplenium gracillimum hen & chickens ferns are Asplenium hookerianum and the cave spleenwort, Asplenium cimmeriorum.

 The cave spleenwort, Asplenium cimmeriorum, is related to the hen & chickens ferns but doesn't produce bulbils. It is found in limestone areas, including caves, around Waitomo and the north-west of the South Island. Photo by Leon Perrie, Curator. (c) Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa.

The cave spleenwort, Asplenium cimmeriorum, is related to the hen & chickens ferns but doesn't produce bulbils. It is found in limestone areas, including caves, around Waitomo and the north-west of the South Island. Photo by Leon Perrie, Curator. (c) Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa.

The false hen and chickens fern

Most hen & chickens ferns in cultivation are the false hen & chickens fern, Asplenium ×lucrosum, rather than Asplenium bulbiferumThe two are easily distinguished.

Asplenium ×lucrosum is a sterile hybrid between Asplenium bulbiferum and Asplenium dimorphum.  The “×” preceding “lucrosum” indicates it is a hybrid.

Fronds with (left) and without (right) reproductive structures, of the same individual of Asplenium ×lucrosum.  Asplenium ×lucrosum inherited this frond dimorphism (having two forms) from Norfolk Island’s Asplenium dimorphum. Photo by Leon Perrie, Curator. (c) Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa.

Fronds with (left) and without (right) spore-producing structures, of the same individual of Asplenium ×lucrosum. Asplenium ×lucrosum inherited this frond dimorphism (having two forms) from Norfolk Island’s Asplenium dimorphum. Photo by Leon Perrie, Curator. (c) Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa.

Bulbils (‘chickens’) of Asplenium ×lucrosum.  Asplenium ×lucrosum inherited the production of bulbils from New Zealand’s Asplenium bulbiferum. This part of the frond is trying to make spores, and is consequently narrowly dissected.  In this image the spore-producing structures are just visible as orange lines poking out from the underside of the frond. Photo by Leon Perrie, Curator. (c) Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa.

Bulbils (‘chickens’) of Asplenium ×lucrosum. Asplenium ×lucrosum inherited the production of bulbils from New Zealand’s Asplenium bulbiferum. This part of the frond is trying to make spores, and is consequently narrowly dissected. In this image the spore-producing structures are just visible as orange lines poking out from the underside of the frond. Photo by Leon Perrie, Curator. (c) Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa.

The two parent species – Asplenium bulbiferum  and Asplenium dimorphum – don’t occur together naturally, Asplenium bulbiferum being naturally found only in New Zealand and Asplenium dimorphum only on Norfolk Island.  However, by 1831 both had been taken to grow in Britain.  This is probably where they hybridised, producing Asplenium ×lucrosum, which is now cultivated around the world.

1831 was when Allan Cunningham returned to England from his botanical explorations in Australasia; he is one of the few botanists to have visited both Norfolk Island and New Zealand by that early time.  We know from his writings that he sent home live plants of Asplenium dimorphum.  We also know that he collected Asplenium bulbiferum, and he may well have been responsible for its live export too. 

Like many hybrids, the false hen & chickens fern is unable to reproduce sexually, its spores being abnormally formed.  However, it can be propagated vegetatively via its bulbils.  This is how it is produced for sale, and also how it has become a minor weed in some parts of New Zealand.

Perhaps because it has ‘hybrid vigour’ and is easier to grow, Asplenium ×lucrosum is the hen & chickens fern usually sold.  The name “lucrosum” reflects its lucrative cultivation for horticulturalists dealing in ferns.

Te Papa’s herbarium holds the type specimen of Asplenium ×lucrosum, images of which are available via Te Papa’s Collections Online.

We formally described Asplenium ×lucrosum in this publication:
Perrie LR, Shepherd LD, Brownsey PJ. 2005. Asplenium ×lucrosum nothosp. nov.: a sterile hybrid widely and erroneously cultivated as “Asplenium bulbiferum”.  Plant Systematics and Evolution 250: 243-257.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 273 other followers